Archivist Confirms Rampley's Carthage College "Academy" Attendance

It is always good to confirm suspicions when possible.

A recent post about James Edward Rampley indicated that I had probably determined why he was listed an attendee of Carthage College in the 1890s and yet only showing on a 1940 census enumeration as having attended school through the 6th grade.

A private email from the archivist at Carthage College today confirmed my suspiscions. It says in part:

 Edward attended the Carthage Academy during the academic years 1893-94 and 1894-95 and was from Hickory Ridge, IL.  The Academy was a prep school associated with the college...

It seems possible that Rampley's parents wanted him to have more education that he could get within walking distance (or a horse trip) from his home in rural southern Hancock County. I am reasonably certain there was no nearby high school, but am not aware of just how many grades of education were available locally.

At this point, I'm not going to analyze the ages of Rampley's classmates. Given that the archivist confirmed my assumption about the Academy, such work seems like overkill and not a productive use of my research time.

I wanted to make certain that the Edward Rampley shown in the catalog was actually the James Edward Rampley I already knew about (son of James and Elizabeth (Newman) Rampley) and not a "new" one. Sometimes when researching unusual names, the researcher never likes to have any unknown people with the last name hanging around as a loose end. Based upon the archivist's email, I don't have a new Rampley in Hickory Ridge, Hancock County, Illinois.

If only I could have found out his grades.

Note: the Carthage College Catalog (1890-1902) is online at Hathitrust. Just click on "full view."

Rampley Was Not Exactly A College Student in 1893

I think I've got the answer to why the "college" attendee of the 1890s indicated in the 1940 census that he had only gone through the 6th grade. It wasn't the census that was wrong. It was my research that was incomplete.

Page 21 of the "Carthage College Catalog 1890-1895" on Mocavo.com suggests the reason:

Edward Rampley was in the "Middle and Junior Classes" of the Academic Department which is descried in the image above. The Academic Department was "designed for those preparing for college." When I went back and read the pages before the Rampley entry, there were entries for the "College" and the senior, junior, sophomore, and freshmen classes within the College. The "Academic Department" was styled as an "Academy" in the catalog, but was intended to prepare students for college work.

Rampley wasn't really attending Carthage College.

The 1940 census for Rampley implies a birth year of approximately 1879. This is consistent with what is known about Rampley. This would have made him approximately 14 when he attended in 1893--a little young for traditional college attendance during this time period.

What I also could have done, but chose not to based upon these two discoveries, was to have searched for Rampley's classmates in the census to approximate their ages. If the description of the "Academic Department" had not made the purpose of it clear, the ages of Rampley's classmates might have suggested that he really was not attending the College itself.

Genealogy Lessons:

• Don't assume the census is wrong. In this case it was correct.
• Read the entire document--the earlier section of the catalog explained what the "Academic Department" was.
• Look at the neighbors for clues--in this case classmates. Their ages would have suggested that Rampley (and they) were not traditional aged college students.
• Avoid drawing conclusions until the research is really done. 

The original post about James Edward Rampley is here. 

A Rampley Goes to College in the 1890s

Nothing is ever as it seems on the surface.

Mocavo.com has a database entitled "Carthage College Catalog 1890-1895." I was surprised to notice the name of a probable relative, Edward Rampley, showing as a member of the "Middle and Junior Classes."

I was surprised for two reasons. The first was that I never thought of looking for any of my paternal relatives in a college setting before World War I. All my families during this time period were rural and didn't attend college. Generally speaking, members of both families attended school to the point of being able to read, ride, and perform basic arithmetic. That's what farmers neededto be able to do. This usually meant grade school attendance or maybe going through the eighth grade. None of my family during this time attended high school, let alone college.

The second thing that struck me was that a paternal relative attended. Carthage College is affiliated with the Lutheran Church and was located in Carthage through the 1950s (today it is in Kenosha, Wisconsin). My father's family were members of a variety of Protestant denominations, but most were not Lutheran. My mother's family was Lutheran, very German Lutheran. Several of my mother's aunts and uncles attended or graduated from Carthage College and numerous other family members either attended for a time or graduated as well. 

Another thing didn't make sense. I didn't remember seeing any relative of Edward's generation indicate college education in their 1940 census enumeration. The first member of my father's family to attend college was my Grandpa Neill's sister who graduated in the 1930s. I'd located all my "immediate" family in 1940 and would have noticed college for someone of Edward's age in 1940.

Sure enough, reviewing Edward's 1940 enumeration indicated he only attended through the 6th grade. He obviously didn't just "guess" at the educational levels as he indicated his son Lester had completed three years of high school.

1940 US Census,Walker, Hancock, Illinois, NARA microfilm publication  T627, roll 810
Page: 9B, Enumeration District 34-39; digital image, Ancestry.com, 5 March 2014.

Enumerated as "James Edward" in 1940, I was fairly certain the Edward in the Carthage College listing was the same person. James Edward Rampley was the son of James Rampley, who in turn was the son of another James Rampley. When James Edward was born, he would have been the third James. Even thought James the grandfather died in 1884, it doesn't seem odd that James Edward would still be using Edward in the 1890s. Nicknames tend to stick. In fact the 1920 and 1930 census enumerations show him as J. Edward and Edward respectively (both in Walker Township as in 1940).

However, I wanted to be certain that I had the right person in the college listing. The college catalog appears to leave off the name of the state when the intended residence is in Illinois. There's only one Breckenridge in Illinois--located in Hancock County, Illinois, in the same township where James Edward is living in 1940.

My memory told me there was no other Edward in the time period, but memory can be wrong, so...

I reviewed the other Rampleys in the Breckenridge area who would have been of an age to attend Carthage College in 1894. They were all first cousins of James Edward and are relatively well-documented. There were no other Rampleys with Edward as a middle or first name. The reference to the Edward Rampley in the 1894 college catalog has to be same person as in the 1940 census listing above.

But if James Edward provided the information himself in 1940 (indicated by the "x") how could he mix up attended college with going through the 6th grade? Was the census taker incorrect?

We'll have an answer to that in a future post. Stay tuned.